Bodnars Bids and Banter
Step into the thrilling world of auctions with Bodnar’s Bids and Banter! Join auctioneer extraordinaire Joe Bodnar and his lively crew as they take you behind the scenes of one of the busiest auction houses around. From rare collectibles and antique treasures to quirky finds and jaw-dropping deals, each episode showcases the excitement of the bidding wars and the stories behind the items up for grabs. With Joe’s quick wit and infectious energy, the show blends the fast-paced action of live auctions with heartwarming tales, unexpected surprises, and plenty of laughs. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or just curious about the thrill of the chase, Bodnar’s Bids and Banter is your ticket to the ultimate auction adventure!
Listen on:
Episodes
Monday Apr 14, 2025
Monday Apr 14, 2025
In this episode, we go deep into the wild world of auctions—featuring smutty comic books that sold for thousands, a $5,000 Star Wars box lost and found a year later, and the team’s honest thoughts on online trolls, negative reviews, and shipping disasters.
The crew also opens up about the stress of packing giant pop culture sales, why photographing toys is a nightmare, and how it felt when one of their podcast clips went mini-viral.
🔥 Topics Covered:
How "smut sells" dominated the latest comic book sale
A shipping horror story from Australia—featuring crushed boxes and happy endings
A peek behind the curtain: responding to negative Google reviews & trolls
The difficulty of photographing reflective toys and handling angry bidders
Why some buyers don’t want others to know about Bodnar’s… and how that affects reviews
What’s coming in the final installment of the McFarlane Toys collection sale
💬 Join the Conversation:Have you had a ridiculous customer experience or shipping disaster? Tell us your story at:📩 bodnarsbidsandbanterpodcast@gmail.com
🔗 Browse Our Upcoming Auctions:🌐 BodnarsAuction.com
📲 Follow Us:Instagram: @BodnarsAuctionFacebook: @BodnarsAuction
Monday Mar 31, 2025
Monday Mar 31, 2025
This week’s episode is a rollercoaster of auction adventures, shocking stories, and real-world tips. Joe, Maureen, Danny, and Tracy dive into the world of scammy art sales, vintage collectibles, and bizarre behind-the-scenes mishaps (including wasp attacks and misplaced orchids!).
We also preview our upcoming art auction, spotlighting a wild range of items from high-end lithographs to bronzes and Victorian revival pieces. Plus, don’t miss Joe’s Beyond the Gavel segment—where a broken totem pole shocked everyone with its final bid.
🔥 Topics Covered:
The dark side of TV art auctions and how they trick buyers
Auction war stories: setup fails, acrylic cases gone wrong, and bee invasions 🐝
Inside GIA: What it’s really like to study diamonds at the Gemological Institute of America
Why market manipulation is a real threat—and how reputable auctions do it differently
Beyond the Gavel: How a busted totem pole sold for over $2,600!
💬 Join the Conversation:Ever made or missed a big score at an auction? Tell us your story or send it to:📩 bodnarsbidsandbanterpodcast@gmail.com
🔗 Explore Our Upcoming Auctions:🌐 BodnarsAuction.com
📲 Follow Us:
Instagram: @BodnarsAuction
Facebook: @BodnarsAuction
Monday Mar 17, 2025
Monday Mar 17, 2025
This episode is one for the books! Join Joe Bodnar, his father, and his son as they share stories from three generations of auctioneers. From the very first Bodnar sale to the massive auctions of today, we take a look at how the business has evolved—and all the chaos that comes with it!
🔥 Topics Covered:
The first-ever Bodnar auction and how it all started 🏛️
Crazy auction memories—from stolen goods to unexpected bidding wars
The worst auction fails—including an entire sale ruined by rain 🌧️
Why collecting trains, antiques, and memorabilia runs in the family
The strangest customer encounters we’ve ever had
💬 Join the Conversation:What’s your most memorable auction experience? Tell us your story in the comments!
🔗 Check Out Our Upcoming Auctions:🌐 BodnarsAuction.com
📲 Follow Us on Social Media:📸 Instagram: @BodnarsAuction📘 Facebook: @BodnarsAuction
Monday Mar 03, 2025
Monday Mar 03, 2025
This episode is jam-packed with some of the craziest stories yet! Joe, Maureen, Erica, and Tracy tackle everything from LEGO and Funko Pop trends to bizarre customer interactions—including a flogging incident that left us speechless! We also break down the latest auction results, discuss why some collectibles are skyrocketing, and share behind-the-scenes moments from our biggest sales.
🔥 Topics Covered:
LEGO madness! How some sets are worth $1,000+
Boba Fett & Star Wars auctions—Did this figure go for a fair price?
The most insane customer experience EVER… and it involves flogging 😳
Why non-paying bidders hurt auctions—and how we deal with them 🚨
Funko Pop trends—Are they still worth collecting?
Monday Feb 17, 2025
Monday Feb 17, 2025
This episode is packed with customer chaos! Joe, Maureen, Janet, Tracy, and Erica dive into the wildest stories from the auction world—including fake names, outrageous customer calls, and one hoarder who called three times a day! Plus, get an exclusive sneak peek at the upcoming comic book auction featuring rare key issues and collectibles.
🔥 Topics Covered:
Who is Dolores? The fake alias used for difficult customers!
That time Joe accidentally became "John Bodnar" thanks to a printing mistake.
Myrna, the hoarder who made bizarre requests from a nursing home.
How customer service in the auction world gets out of control.
Preview of our upcoming comic book sale—major key issues and hot collectibles!
💬 Join the Conversation:Have you ever dealt with a bizarre customer or wild phone call? Tell us your story in the comments!
🔗 Check Out Our Upcoming Auctions:🌐 BodnarsAuction.com
📲 Follow Us on Social Media:📸 Instagram: @BodnarsAuction📘 Facebook: @BodnarsAuction
Monday Feb 03, 2025
Monday Feb 03, 2025
This episode is packed with auction-world chaos! Joe, Maureen, Janet, Tracy, and Erica dive into the reality of fire-damaged antiques, extreme hoarder house cleanouts, and the unexpected collectibles that come from it all. From a jaw-dropping Dresden collection to the debate over saving a historic Freehold Raceway program, this episode is full of auction knowledge, behind-the-scenes stories, and plenty of laughs.
🔥 Topics Covered:
What happens when antiques survive a fire?
Hoarder house horrors: How do you handle extreme clutter?
The Dresden collection that took years to assemble—and minutes to sell!
Can modern collectibles, like raceway programs, become valuable in the future?
The ongoing evolution of Bodnar’s Auctions and what’s next for the business.
💬 Join the Conversation:What’s the most unusual or fire-damaged collectible you’ve ever come across? Share your thoughts in the comments or message us—we’d love to hear your stories!
🔗 Check Out Our Upcoming Auctions:🌐 BodnarsAuction.com
📲 Follow Us on Social Media:📸 Instagram: @BodnarsAuction📘 Facebook: @BodnarsAuction
Monday Jan 20, 2025
Monday Jan 20, 2025
In this action-packed episode of Bodnar’s Bids and Banter Podcast, Joe, Maureen, Danny, and Tracy share jaw-dropping stories from the auction world. From uncovering haunted items to handling radioactive materials, this episode is full of unforgettable moments. Plus, the team dives into an incredible collection of Star Wars collectibles, including rare graded action figures and autographed items.
Sunday Jan 12, 2025
Sunday Jan 12, 2025
In the second episode of Bodnar's Bids and Banter, Joe Bodnar and his team share hilarious stories of auction mishaps and colorful characters, including the memorable antics of their longtime employee, Jeff. With festive holiday vibes and a few surprising revelations, this episode is packed with laughter, camaraderie, and a glimpse into the wild world of auctions.